Key takeaways
- In almost every case, yes: a Facebook or Instagram page complements a website but does not replace it.
- Social media is great for community and reach, but you do not own it and it has nowhere to send people next.
- Google and AI assistants mostly surface websites, not social profiles, when people search for services.
- The strongest setup uses both: social to grab attention, a website to convert enquiries and get found.
In almost every case, yes, you still need a website. A Facebook or Instagram page is a brilliant way to stay in touch with customers, but it is not a substitute for a home of your own on the web. Social media is rented space with someone else’s rules, someone else’s design and someone else’s algorithm deciding who sees you. A website is the one place online that you fully control, and it is where Google, AI assistants and serious buyers go looking for proof that your business is real.
What social media does well
Let us give credit where it is due. Facebook and Instagram are excellent for building community, showing your personality and reaching people who were not looking for you. Posts, stories and reels keep your business in front of past customers, and messaging makes it easy for people to ask quick questions. For many Australian small businesses, social media is where the first hello happens.
The trouble starts when that first hello has nowhere to go next.
Where a page on its own falls short
- You do not own it. Accounts get hacked, restricted or suspended every day, often with no warning and no easy way to appeal. If your page disappears tomorrow, your whole online presence goes with it.
- The algorithm decides who sees you. Even people who follow you may never see your posts. Reach on business pages has been shrinking for years, and the usual fix is paying to boost posts.
- It is hard to find anything. Your opening hours, prices, services and FAQs end up buried in a feed. A website puts each of these on its own clear page.
- Some customers are not on the platform. Plenty of people have no Facebook or Instagram account, and a login wall between a customer and your information costs you enquiries.
- It can look less credible. Many buyers, especially for higher-value purchases, expect a proper website. No website can read as no established business.
Google and AI assistants look for a website
When someone searches for “plumber Penrith” or “gallery Darwin”, Google mostly shows websites, not social pages. Social profiles rank for your business name at best, and rarely for the services people actually search, which is one reason so many businesses wonder why they are not showing up on Google. The same goes for AI assistants like ChatGPT and Google’s AI results, which draw heavily on website content when recommending businesses. If your only presence is a social page, you are close to invisible in both search and AI answers. A well-structured site is the foundation of the SEO and GEO work that gets you found.
The good news: they work best together
This is not a choice between a website and social media. The strongest setup uses both, each doing what it does best. Social media grabs attention and builds relationships. Your website turns that attention into enquiries and sales, with clear service pages, pricing, testimonials and a contact form that works. Every post you publish can point back to a page you own, and that page keeps working long after the post has slid down the feed.
A simple, well-built site does not need to be huge either. Even five pages, done properly, will outperform a page-only presence. If you are starting from scratch, a WordPress website gives you full ownership of your content and room to grow into online bookings or a shop later. And if paid social or broader digital strategy is on your radar, our friends at Defyn Digital can help the two channels pull in the same direction.
A sensible first step
Keep your Facebook and Instagram pages active, but treat them as the front door, not the house. Start with a small website that answers the questions customers actually ask: what you do, where you are, what it costs and how to get in touch. Link to it from every social profile and post.
Thinking about making the move from page to proper website? We build sites for businesses across Sydney and beyond. Call us on 02 9834 4119 or get in touch for a friendly, no-pressure chat.
Need a WordPress website, theme or plugin built properly? We would love to help.
Start a project



